Chelsea Vs Everton Head-to-Head: A Rivalry in Numbers

Chelsea vs Everton head-to-head has delivered drama, twists, and historical moments. In this article, AvigGoal will escort you through the full story — who leads the series, the biggest wins, trend shifts across eras, and what recent form suggests for future clashes.

Table of Contents

Historical Overview: Roots of the Rivalry

The first meetings between Chelsea and Everton date back over a century, as both clubs established themselves in English top-flight football. Over the decades, their encounters have spanned league campaigns, FA Cup ties, and domestic cups — each adding layers to the rivalry.

According to comprehensive head-to-head data, the two clubs have met in around 182 competitive matches, with Chelsea winning 69 and Everton 56, and 57 draws.
In league play and especially since the Premier League era, Chelsea have built a stronger edge, though Everton have delivered memorable shocks.
The aggregate goals in those contests tilt slightly in favour of Chelsea, though some sources suggest Everton have scored more in certain aggregations — evidence that margins can shift depending on which time spans are considered.

The rivalry has seen periods of dominance by one side or the other, but it’s never been lopsided forever. Chelsea’s financial rise in the 21st century allowed them to deepen that advantage, but Everton’s spirit and occasional bursts of greatness have kept them competitive.

Head-to-Head By Competition

Let’s break down how Chelsea vs Everton head-to-head plays out across different competitions and venues.

Premier League / League Matches

Since the inception of the Premier League, the two sides have clashed many times. In that period, Chelsea have enjoyed more frequent victories.
For instance, in top-flight matches, Chelsea have won around 64 of those encounters, Everton 55, with 53 draws.
Home advantage has mattered: at Stamford Bridge, Chelsea have been stronger; at Goodison Park, Everton have had their moments.

Cup Ties & Domestic Cups

In FA Cup and League Cup encounters, the head-to-head becomes more balanced and fewer in number.
A standout moment was the 2009 FA Cup Final, when Chelsea edged Everton 2–1 in a high-stakes showdown to lift the trophy.
Cup matches often throw unpredictability, which occasionally swings momentum back toward the underdog.

Venue Breakdown

Venue	Chelsea Wins	Everton Wins	Draws
Stamford Bridge	Strong showing by Chelsea	Occasional Everton upsets	Several draws
Goodison Park	Fewer wins for Chelsea	Everton have capitalized more	Many shared points

The away side has had mixed success. While Chelsea have regularly won at Goodison in some seasons, Everton have also managed to frustrate Chelsea in league and cup clashes at home.

Memorable Matches & Records

No head-to-head story is complete without key matches and milestones that fans still talk about.

Biggest Chelsea win vs Everton: One of the most recent emphatic results was a 6–0 demolition, where Chelsea overwhelmed Everton in a display of total dominance.
Biggest Everton win vs Chelsea: Perhaps the most striking counter was Everton’s 6–0 win in 1978 over Chelsea — a result still often recalled by longtime Toffees supporters.
2009 FA Cup Final: Everton looked like they might shock the strong favorites, but Chelsea turned it late to claim the silverware — an emotionally charged moment in the rivalry.
Recent tight matches: A 1–0 win for Chelsea in April 2025 reaffirmed their ability to grind out results in high stakes.

These matches showcase that while Chelsea often hold the edge, Everton are capable of delivering joy — and pain — to their rivals.

Recent Trends & Recent Data

To understand where this rivalry stands today, we need to look at recent matches, form, and subtle shifts in statistical advantage.

In recent head-to-heads, Chelsea recorded 17 wins, Everton 11, and 13 ended in draws.
Many matches tend to have over 1.5 goals, but over 2.5 goals is less common, suggesting tight defensive battles.
In recent seasons, Chelsea have had the up.
Regarding clean sheets, Chelsea have often been better at keeping a shutout in these clashes than Everton.
In particular, their 1–0 matches underscore how thin the margins are: one defensive lapse or finishing touch often defines the result.

These recent patterns show a continuation of Chelsea’s overall dominance, but that Everton is never far off — especially on a good day.

Why Chelsea Often Come Out On Top

What gives Chelsea the edge in the Chelsea vs Everton head-to-head contest? Several factors:

Squad depth and resources: In modern football, Chelsea’s financial firepower allows consistent investment in star players and squad rotation, which helps over a season.
Tactical evolution: Chelsea have often adapted more fluid systems under managers to counter Everton’s setups.
Consistency in top-flight status: Chelsea have remained a near-constant in elite competitions, whereas Everton have faced more fluctuations and disruption.
Home advantage and psychological edge: Chelsea’s home record in this rivalry is strong, and their players often enter matches as favorites.

However, it’s not one-sided: Everton’s moments of brilliance, set-piece strength, and ability to counterpunch keep Chelsea wary in every fixture.

What to Watch in Future Encounters

When the two sides meet next, several storylines will likely emerge:

Fine margins: Many past matches decided by a single goal or set-piece — expect the next one to be tight.
Tactical chess match: Everton may adopt defensive resilience and break quickly, while Chelsea will aim to dominate possession and force the issue.
Key players: Strikers and creative midfielders often determine the outcome. A clinical finish or moment of magic could tilt the balance.
Momentum & form: Whoever carries better rhythm into the match — both in league and cup — may have the psychological up.
Injury and squad rotation: Depth matters. If either side is dealing with injury problems or fatigue, that can swing results.

These factors make each Chelsea vs Everton head-to-head clash unpredictable and always worth watching.

Final Thoughts

In sum, Chelsea vs Everton head-to-head reflects over a century of competition — a story of elite dominance, spirited underdog performances, and footballing drama. Chelsea lead in most metrics: wins, consistency, and big victories. Yet Everton’s flashes of brilliance and their capacity for surprise remind us they’re never out of the fight.

As new seasons come and new stars emerge, this rivalry continues evolving. For fans craving match previews, statistics, player narratives, or historical dives — AvigGoal is your companion through every twist.

Do you want a breakdown of top goal scorers in Chelsea vs Everton head-to-head or a full timeline match list? Just let me know — AvigGoal will bring it next.